Alone Yet Not Alone is a riveting historical drama based on a true story by Tracy Leininger Craven. It captures the violence during the French and Indian War when the two daughters of a German-American family are taken captive during a tribal attack. The oldest daughter Barbara (Natalie Racoosin and Kelly Greyson) maintains her faith throughout the difficult years by holding on to the words of the family’s favorite hymn, “Alone Yet Not Alone”. 



I came in with high expectations for this movie and it managed to exceed my expectations. I was already familiar with the story since I’d read the book, and George Escobar and James Richards did a fantastic job of bringing the book to life on the big screen. There were a few minor changes from the book, but overall, they maintained the spirit of the story perfectly. 

I absolutely loved the cinematography. In addition to the breathtaking settings, I was impressed with the camera and choreography techniques such as the camera booms that revealed multiple vignettes all lined up on a hillside and the handheld jerky camera during times of turmoil and confusion. 

The acting throughout the movie was top notch. The female leads (Joanie Stewart, Kelly Greyson, Jenn Gotzon, and Natalie Racoosin) were particularly strong. If I didn’t know better, I would assume that Joanie always spoke with a German accent. And Jenn’s portrayal of Lydia being burned on the stake gave me chills. Her approach was so unexpected and yet so right. 

The only negative with the acting was that I didn’t feel the male roles were quite as fleshed out as the female roles. We were told that Galasko was the gentler brother and Hannawoa the evil one, but with the exception of the proposal scene and the cross country chase, we didn’t get to see the contrast as vividly as I would have liked. 

I would highly recommend this movie for anyone middle school or older. It would be a great resource for homeschoolers of other history lovers as it brings the French and Indian War to life. It’s also one of those rare movies that can be appreciated equally by men and women with its mix of intense action and tender moments. 

Joanie Stewart at the Nashville screening.


Alone Yet Not Alone played in select theaters this past weekend. It opens in the rest of the country in February. Be sure to check it out when it comes to your town! 

About the Author Sharon Wilharm

Sharon Wilharm is a female filmmaker, blogger, and speaker. Her movies have screened in theaters, festivals, and churches around the globe, aired on multiple television networks, and sold in stores and online outlets throughout English speaking countries. She's accumulated dozens of festival accolades including the “Shibboleth Award for Visionary Leadership in the Field of Christian Film Making”, numerous Best of Fest awards, and 4 ICVM Crown Awards. She's passionate about storytelling and loves entertaining and inspiring audiences with her filmmaking, writing, and speaking.


  1. The portrayal of Native Americans in this movie was abhorrent and extremely prejudicial and racist. This is inexcusable. The acting, with the exception of Jenn Gotzen, was atrocious and so very unbelievable. The cinemotography was awesome, though.


    1. Spoken like a true liberal!
      I mean really who are you to judge whether the indians were terribly misportrayed? Were you ever taken captive by Indians, dragged 300 miles from home after watching them kill and scalp your father and brother? I mean these were after all savages were talking about. Were they mistreated by the British and later Americans? Yes, but that does not change the fact that they did do these atrocious things. So please get off this prejudicial and racist characterization nonsense.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.